
26 Sept 2026
Karthik Subbaraj’s padam — Dorothy — brings trans and queer love into the centre of a mainstream Tamil film. In doing so, it touches upon questions of gender, masculinity, love and acceptance that continue to challenge conventional ideas of identity.
Stories like these often become a point of debate because they disturb familiar ideas of what love and identity are supposed to look like. They make us question not only who we accept, but also what we believe has always been acceptable.
And that raises a more interesting question.
How new is this, really?
The tendency to describe queer love as modern, Western or imported does not sit comfortably with India’s own cultural history.
Long before modern terms such as gay, transgender or queer entered contemporary public discourse, Indian literature, mythology, religious traditions and artistic practices had already imagined forms of desire, identity and gender that did not always fit neatly into conventional categories.
The Kama Sutra, composed in ancient India, includes discussions of same-sex acts and people who existed outside conventional male-female sexual roles. Historical scholarship has also documented same-sex erotic practices and relationships in different periods of South Asian history.
The Mahabharata gives us Shikhandi, a figure whose story unsettles straightforward ideas of gender. Born as Shikhandini, Shikhandi eventually lives as a man and becomes instrumental in Bhishma’s fall. The story should not be read as a modern account of transgender identity. Yet it demonstrates that questions of gender transformation were already present within one of India’s most influential epics.

Then there is Aravan and Mohini.
According to the tradition associated with Koovagam, Aravan agrees to sacrifice himself for the Pandavas but asks to be married before his death. Krishna assumes the form of Mohini and marries him. After Aravan’s sacrifice, Mohini mourns him as a widow.
The story lives on at the annual Koovagam festival in Tamil Nadu, where the marriage and mourning are ritually re-enacted and have become closely associated with the cultural identity of transgender communities.
These stories should not be casually labelled “gay” or “transgender” in the modern sense. The people and societies that produced them did not necessarily understand identity through today’s categories.
But that distinction leads to an important point:
The vocabulary may be new. The human experiences are not.
India’s cultural history does not offer one simple story of acceptance. There have been periods and communities in which same-sex desire and gender variance were represented, accommodated, celebrated or ritualised. There have also been periods of social and legal repression.
The history is complicated.
But complicated is not the same as absent.
Even the visual language of Indian religious art repeatedly unsettles rigid ideas of gender. Ardhanarishvara, the composite form of Shiva and Parvati, represents masculine and feminine aspects within a single divine body. It is not a representation of homosexuality, nor should it be forced into a modern LGBTQ+ framework. Yet it remains a powerful image of a conception of existence in which masculine and feminine are not necessarily sealed into separate and opposing categories.
That distinction matters.
To say that queer people existed in ancient India is not to claim that ancient India was a modern liberal society. Nor does every ancient story involving gender transformation represent contemporary transgender identity or same-sex love.
It is simply to recognise that many strands of India’s cultural and religious history reveal understandings of gender and desire that were more varied than present-day stereotypes often suggest.
So when a film like Dorothy brings trans love and queer identity into mainstream cinema, perhaps the most interesting response is not to ask whether such stories belong in Indian culture.
Perhaps we should ask why we ever thought they did not.
Because queer love is not an aberration that has suddenly appeared in India.
It has been part of the human story here for a very long time.